Details
Identifications/Comments
Identification by geechartier at 2019-12-24 08:22:36
Comment by juhakinnunen at 2020-01-10 11:41:47
Can you see if the antennae are bipectinate or flagellate...
Identification by juhakinnunen at 2022-02-08 11:08:10
Comment by geechartier at 2022-02-14 11:29:27
@juhakinnunen, based on Dubatolov (2010), I was considering re-identifying this as C. gangis. He suggests that the nominate subspecies of C. fasciatus, which is what should be in Cambodia (type location), has less expressed dark markings, and that only the new subspecies, described therein, has dark markings similar to C. gangis. http://szmn.eco.nsc.ru/vvdubat/pdf/EEJ_9(4)727-730.pdf
Comment by juhakinnunen at 2022-02-14 11:38:24
@geechartier Well, for the time being, I am not identifying the species C. gangis at all. Only in India to the complex of interrupta-gangis aggregate, and the reason for my behaviour is this: https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0194200 See especially Fig. 1. And, it may be that even my IDing to that complex is bad since there are separate entities near India (1 in Nepal, 2 in Myanmar). So, summa summarum, we do not know what is what with gangis and its kins.
Comment by geechartier at 2022-02-14 12:54:14
@juhakinnunen, thank you. My reading of the Discussion section suggests that it is safe to ID C. gangis to species level, but the subspecies level is, as yet, unclear. The paper even suggests that C. omanirana should be considered a subspecies of C. gangis. Unfortunately, the paper does not cover C. fasciatus.
Comment by juhakinnunen at 2022-02-14 14:31:41
@geechartier I think we have not heard the last word of this yet. To me, the most bewildering part of the tree are those that are not part of the main gangis-tree: gang34 (Middle Andaman), gang11 (Myanmar) and gang 14-15 (Thailand). That means that they are not very close to what we consider to be gangis sensu stricto. Why so? Australia and Lesser Sundas are in the main tree but some small populations have started evolving to new directions...!